← All comparisons
All About Reading vs Logic of English: Structured Phonics Compared
All About Reading and Logic of English are both popular with families who want explicit, multisensory reading instruction. The difference is usually scripted reading support versus a broader structured-literacy system.
Quick verdict
Choose All About Reading for a highly scripted reading path. Choose Logic of English for a broader phonograms, spelling, handwriting, and language system.
Side-by-side comparison
Decision factor
All About Reading
Logic of English
Best fit
Parents wanting open-and-go reading lessons
Families wanting integrated reading and spelling rules
Approach
Orton-Gillingham, multi-sensory phonics
Structured literacy, Orton-Gillingham influenced, multisensory phonics
Grade range
PreK–6
PreK–Adult
Faith fit
Faith-Neutral
Secular
Typical annual cost
$50–$140
$150–$450
Parent prep
All About Reading keeps parent prep manageable because the sequence is already laid out. Parents still need to check work and adjust pacing, but the planning burden is lower than a fully custom curriculum.
Logic of English is parent-involved. Expect to preview lessons, read or teach directly, and keep the weekly plan moving. It can be very effective, but it is not a true hands-off option.
Choose All About Reading if…
Faith-NeutralStructuredDyslexia-FriendlyKinestheticVisual
- ✓Parents wanting open-and-go reading lessons
- ✓Beginning or struggling readers
- ✓Families who want reading separated from spelling decisions
Choose Logic of English if…
SecularDyslexia-FriendlyReading WritingPhonicsMultisensory
- ✓Families wanting integrated reading and spelling rules
- ✓Students who benefit from explicit phonogram instruction
- ✓Parents willing to learn a fuller structured-literacy method
Key differences parents notice
- •All About Reading is more reading-specific.
- •Logic of English integrates more spelling and language rules.
- •Both are multisensory and often considered by dyslexia-focused families.
FAQ
Which is better for dyslexia?
Both can be strong options. The better fit depends on parent teaching style, student age, and whether you want a scripted reading path or a broader language system.
Do I need a separate spelling program?
With All About Reading, many families add All About Spelling. Logic of English includes more spelling-rule instruction inside the broader system.